When Your Dog Will NOT Stop Pulling On The Leash!

Pippa Mattinson, best-selling author and founder of the Dogsnet Training Program, brings us the latest information on the challenge of dogs with a deeply ingrained pulling habit.

I have written a number of articles about pulling on the leash and how to stop it. But it seems that there is always more to say! 

Number one problem!

There’s always more to say because this is simply one of the biggest problems for owners of large strong dogs.  

In fact, I’d go so far as to say that it’s the number one problem for large dog owners worldwide. 

And it can make life with a dog really miserable. Not to mention hazardous.

Why do they do it?

Dogs pull on the leash because they think that pulling is what keeps them moving in the direction they want to go. 

The reason that leash pulling is such a big problem is because most people inadvertently reward leash pulling in their puppies, (when it doesn’t matter so much). 

And then it becomes an ingrained habit.

How the habit takes hold

Many dogs continue to be rewarded for leash pulling throughout their lives.  

The dog is rewarded either by being let off the leash after pulling,  or by being repeatedly allowed to move in the direction that they are pulling towards.

If your dog drags you to the dog park each day, he is justified in believing that pulling is the only way to get to the dog park. 

The cure?

I can’t rush in and tell you that there is a quick fix for dogs that pull on the leash, because there isn’t. 

The effective, long term cure to pulling on the leash is to teach the dog that walking nicely at your side gets results, and that pulling gets them nowhere. 

It goes without saying that this is not a goal you can achieve in an afternoon!

The bad news 

So, the bad news is that curing leash pulling takes many weeks and much persistence.  It could even take months if your dog has been pulling for months. 

Which is why it’s understandable that so many people give up before they are successful. But there is good news.

The good news

The good news, is that the cure works if you stick at it.  Thousands of dogs with pulling habits have been cured, and your dog can be cured too. 

In the meantime, there are management strategies that you can use to help prevent the problem getting worse, and to keep you and your dog safe. 

Managing a puller

Managing a dog that pulls is a separate issue from training a dog not to pull. 

And it’s an important issue because training takes time, and because pulling is a potentially dangerous behavior, especially in a large dog. 

Harnesses and halters

Body harnesses with front attachments can help give dog owners some control over a hardened puller. As can head collars or halters. 

And though the latter work because they are unpleasant for the dog, they are the lesser of several evils when it comes to providing a temporary control mechanism.

A control mechanism which is necessary in many cases,  to keep the person holding on to the dog safe, and in some cases to keep others safe too.  

Short term solutions

None of these management techniques is ideal, they all either interfere with the dog’s natural movement or behavior, or cause the dog some discomfort.

Pulling management techniques,  should always be considered as a short term solution while the long term solution – training – is being put in place. 

But my dog only pulls when….

Often people are looking for a very specific solution because their dog’s pulling behavior only occurs in specific situations.

Many dogs don’t pull on the leash all the time.  They may

• Pull as they leave the house, or go through doors & gateways
• Pull when they see other dogs
• Pull when they see other people
• Pull when they see vehicles, toys or anything moving fast

The rest of the time these dogs may walk nicely on the leash, and their owner quite understandably assumes that the dog knows how to behave.

This can cause confusion. 

Naughty dogs!

The natural conclusion if a dog knows how to behave, and fails to do so,  is that the dog is choosing to disobey. 

If a dog knows how to walk on a loose leash then surely when they do pull this is due to naughtiness or stubbornness. 

Check out how to train a stubborn dog for some more insight into this problem!

A flawed assumption

For now though, I have to tell you that concluding your dog is stubborn or naughty is almost always a flawed assumption

And it is a flawed assumption that often leads dog owners to give up on training altogether, or resort to painful or abusive solutions such as electric shocks. 

This assumption is flawed because it ignores the fact that all dogs learn based on the context in which that learning took place

Context based learning

The cause of a dogs inability to perform a known skill under distractions is due to a well documented canine attribute. 

This is the poor ability of dogs to apply skills learnt in one situation, to a different one. 

We usually refer to this as an inability to ‘generalize’ and it gets dogs into a whole heap of trouble. Happily, training can overcome this.

Training in different contexts

For all dogs, some contexts are more challenging than others. And every dog is different. Some dogs will struggle to walk nicely past a cat, for example, while another dog may struggle to walk past a child.

Well structured training enables dogs to learn at a simpler level before asking them to perform the same skills in more challenging situations.

The key is to repeat the same training in different contexts starting with the situation that your dog finds easier and working your way up to the most challenging distractions you are likely to meet.

Pulling versus walking to heel

Resolving the problem begins with switching your focus from what the dog is doing wrong (dragging you around on the end of his leash) to what we actually want the dog to do

Then teaching the dog to do that in achievable stages

And what you want the dog to do, is walk nicely alongside of you with their shoulder about level with your left leg. Otherwise known as walking to heel

Walking to heel

Heelwork is the polar opposite of pulling on the leash. The dog cannot pull if they are at heel. 

In the heel position the dog is next to your leg and the leash will be loose.

Heelwork doesn’t have to be ‘competition’ level positioning, but you do need to decide what you expect and make sure that the dog meets those expectations.

How to teach heel

You will need to teach your dog to do this in a very quiet and confined area with no distractions. You won’t even need a leash to begin with.

Then one by one, as your dog succeeds you’ll introduce little distractions and temptations.  Making sure all the time, that your dog can’t get at any rewards if he caves into the temptation to break from the heel position.. 

In other words, the only way he wins, is if he makes the right choice and stays at your side.  You’ll find detailed instructions for teaching heel to your dog in our Core Skills training course. But here are some tips

Getting started

The first stage is to teach your dog that there is huge value in being next to your left leg.

You can do this by feeding your dog repeatedly in this position. In many different locations and contexts.

This isn’t about pushing or pulling your dog into position. Simply place treats on the floor, next to your left foot, many times a day. No force or coercion is needed.

Getting moving

Once the dog is seeking out the position next to your foot repeatedly, the second stage is about getting the dog moving forwards and backwards, over tiny distances.

You can do this next to a wall, fence or other barrier to help the dog keep a nice position facing forwards and next to you.

Including the leash

Teaching the dog to ignore a leash while working with them in the heel position is an important step as you progress.

Because you’ll need to be able to prevent the dog breaking position once you start to add distractions.

Proofing

Teaching a dog walk at your side is actually the easy part. But as we’ve seen, the dog needs to be taught to do this in different contexts. 

This process of adding changes and distractions in incremental stages is what takes the time.  

Trainers call this process ‘proofing’.  And it’s what will enable you to walk your dog past other dogs, other people, etc, without being dragged off to greet them!

Proofing is a skill that you can learn and get better at with practice. And its a skill we teach throughout our training courses. Starting with Foundation Skills

Teaching a dog to walk to heel is hard

I’m not going to tell you that all this will be easy.

Some of the people who start, won’t succeed with teaching their dog to walk to heel.  It’s hard and not everyone wants the cure badly enough to follow through.

Why some people fail

Some won’t use powerful enough rewards often enough and for long enough to get the new behavior established. 

Some won’t set up the training scenarios required to practice in different contexts and to proof their heel work, so that the dog learns to walk at heel past increasingly tempting distractions. 

Or they will skip stages in training so that the dog starts to fail increasingly often.

Your choice

Having a dog that walks politely next to you, no matter where you go, is a wonderful feeling.

The truth though, is that not everyone cares enough, or wants it enough, to invest the time required to succeed. 

But the fact remains, that there is a cure, and that if you are doggedly persistent, you can fix this horrible pulling problem. 

You can do this

Stopping your dog from pulling on the leash is within your grasp.

You can even teach your dog not to pull on the leash past kids and ball games, and when there are other dogs around. 

You will need to invest some time – a few minutes – once or twice a day. And be prepared to stick at it, until the job is done. 

Getting help

If you want the support of a structured training program, to do this, then you can enroll on one of our online training courses. 

Core Skills is where we start to teach heel work, but the best place to begin the training program is with the Foundations Skills course. That course will give you the skills you need, to teach your dog the skills he needs.

You might also enjoy joining my Training Tips list, where I share free videos, tips and fun training guides on a range of different topics.

Just pop your name in the email box below to join the list.